
- Who’s going to take care of them?
I saw yesterday’s NY Times article which quoted Obama commenting on the shortage of primary care physicians and detailed the coming storm over Medicare reimbursement. Essentially, the government is talking about redistributing physician pay so that specialists get less and primary care doctors get more. The specialists are up in arms, of course. They acknowledge that primary care doctors should get paid more, but the specialists clearly shouldn’t give up any of their compensation to make it so. I didn’t actually know how much money doctors made when I went to medical school. I thought maybe a primary care doc made around $100,000 and a specialist made $200,000. My highest salary prior to starting this process was $27,000 a year as a community organizer (on which I was able to live quite comfortably) so I figured anything thereafter was likely going to be an improvement of some sort!
Imagine my shock today when I went to the website http://www.cejkasearch.com/compensation/amga_physician_compensation_survey.htm and found out what enormous amounts of money people I know will be making in the very near future. About 20% of my graduating medical school class at Duke (class of 2009 – coming to Mali put me into class of 2010 now) went into ophthalmology – average salary $305,000 per year. Why would anyone want to care for poor diabetic people with ulcerated feet or help aging AIDS patients manage their 25 different medications when you could do lens replacements, call it a day at 5 pm, spend more time with your kids and make twice as much money?
Everyone comes to medicine for different reasons and I understand the desire for extreme wealth in combination with interesting and helpful work (in the case of ophthalmologists, making the blind see) that isn’t overly stressful. I can’t say why I feel this very strong, almost visceral rejection of the lifestyle specialties to which many people for whom I have a lot of respect seem inexorably drawn. I think that it is mainly because it seems like an unfair twist of government reimbursement plans that a radiologist should make three times as much money as a family practice doctor when they have training of similar duration and are similarly intelligent. My mother is a gastroenterologist, so she is in the category of hugely compensated procedurists. She still thinks it’s crazy to get paid 10 times as much for your time when you do a colonoscopy versus the same amount of time spent in clinic thinking through illness and managing medications. The worst part of this is the way that some medical students begin to talk about and conceptualize primary care. They talk about it as though it is for dumb people, because obviously how much you are paid and your intelligence are so very closely correlated. I have heard people say, “I mean, why would you go to Duke med if you just wanted to do primary care?” I agree with the interventional cardiology fellow who, after flawlessly snaking a catheter into a patient’s heart, told me, “A monkey could be trained to do this. The hard part is thinking about people’s problems and using cognitive abilities to solve them.”
The ophthalmology equivalent here in Mali, ironically, is public health. If you specialize in public health by pursuing post-graduate medical education in Benin or France then you have the potential to work with those unstoppable cash-cows, the NGOs. Nobody aspires to take care of patients because it is time-consuming, depressing, and doesn’t pay at all (a chef de poste medicale at a community health center earns 150,000 cfa or $300 a month!). People even reject surgery as being too low-paying. The outcome is the same as in the U.S. Primary care physicians get paid less and less as people flock to areas where they are better compensated and have a better lifestyle. Oh, and all of the public health specialists live in Bamako whereas the people who need care are spread throughout the bush. And then if you do a bad job taking care of poor, powerless people there are no consequences for your failure just as the rewards for heroic efforts are non-existent. It’s extremely sad.
I think this is all a bunch of crap. I believe that there should be a redistribution of pay, because it isn’t as though a rational and thoughtful process was undertaken to decide current reimbursement schemes! As usual, when it comes to getting government money, it has a lot to do with who has the best lobbyists and connections. Using pay to try to steer people to needed disciplines within medicine would be a very appropriate manifestation of the free market. Is it not generally the case that when there is a shortage of something (say, primary care physicians) that thing becomes more expensive and highly valued? And if people chose something they didn’t feel passionate about doing because of the money, they should realize that that decision was poorly made. Too bad for them. It’s not as if anyone would be poor their salary were reduced from $300,000 to $200,000 a year – it is all so very much more money than 99.9% of people on the planet could dream of having. When asked about the salary issue at a presentation to our first year class, one of the Duke family practice doctors sighed and said, “I am so tired of people complaining about money. Doctors make more money than any other professional group in the U.S. and somehow people still think that it isn’t enough.”
Nowhere else in the world are doctors so much richer than everyone else, nor do they have to work as hard in other parts of the world as in the US. For me, our job is to be enthusiastic and competent at taking care of people and to realize that there are different ways of providing this care but that none is superior to the others. My colleagues doing neurosurgery aren’t better or smarter than my colleagues doing family medicine, they just have different priorities and interests. Everyone needs to be nurtured and appreciated in their work, as we cannot function if any part of our system is missing. And we need more doctors so that we can take care of everyone and still have time to take care of ourselves. So I think we should do what it takes to have enough primary care docs and we should appreciate those who have chosen that path! Right now I am planning to pursue a residency in internal medicine, and I’m not sure what will come next. But I haven’t ruled out being an internist or a hospitalist. I always felt that my future was in Africa, but hearing of the physician shortage in the U.S. makes me remember the myriad issues of justice and access to care that continue to plague my home, the richest country in the world.